Browse Property Management in Key West, FL. Use the sort controls to compare ratings, review counts, activity, and profile details.
Compare management
Request property-management proposals in Key West, FL
Share the property type, address, rental status, timing, current use, and owner goals for RealReviews to review and potentially share with selected managers.
✓ Owner-specific brief✓ Choose local managers✓ No representation agreement
Verify address-specific rental eligibility and review the complete management agreement.
★5.0 · 5 ReviewsReported by Google Places · not a RealReviews rating
Real Estate Management of Key West is a locally owned Key West company at 3706 North Roosevelt Boulevard that publishes home-watch, long-term rental, HOA and condominium, accounting, inspection, emergency-contact, and vendor-oversight services. The official material supports a monitoring and management model, but owners should separate work the company observes or coordinates from licensed trade work and obtain the actual checklist, authority limits, reporting cadence, fees, and contract exit terms.
Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available
HOA and condominium managementHome watchLong-term property management+4
★5.0 · 1 ReviewReported by Google Places · not a RealReviews rating
BDM Property Solutions is a Key West property-management business whose current official site advertises rental administration and community-association management. Its rental material names tenant placement, rent collection, maintenance coordination, tenant transitions, financial and administrative support, reporting, and Key West-area placement. The broader site also presents services for homeowners associations and condominiums. The public evidence does not establish a complete transient-vacation-rental operation, and it does not publish the legal entity that signs a management agreement, a complete fee schedule, repair authority, reserve, owner payout calendar, storm attachment, or termination process. BBB lists a Key Plaza mailing or business address and reports a Florida credential, but that secondary disclosure is not a substitute for a current direct DBPR record. RealReviews found too little individual review evidence to describe recurring customer sentiment. BDM is therefore best compared as two possible service lines—rental administration and association management—with the contract, credentials, pricing, repair authority, reporting cadence, storm responsibilities, insurance, renewal, and exit terms determining fit.
Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available
★4.9 · 151 ReviewsReported by Google Places · not a RealReviews rating
Historic Key West Vacation Rentals is a boutique vacation-rental and property-management company at 1119 White Street with a current official site, matching 305-296-1010 phone, owner portal, nightly and monthly inventory, guest services, rental policies, and a property-management inquiry path. Its public materials do not publish the owner agreement, complete fee schedule, sample statement, after-hours staffing plan, or termination handoff.
Review data available · Quote request available · Claim available
★4.7 · 497 ReviewsReported by Google Places · not a RealReviews rating
VHKW - Vacation Homes of Key West is a Key West vacation-rental manager at 507 Whitehead Street. Its current owner page advertises marketing and booking technology, housekeeping, maintenance, guest services, and support with licensing, taxes, and legal requirements. The official legal disclosure identifies Molly Parker, Inc. doing business as Vacation Homes of Key West, and the inspected Florida filing showed Molly Parker, Inc., document P02000018690, as active at the same address on July 26, 2026. That identity evidence does not make a separate owner's property eligible for transient rental; the address and intended rental frequency require their own current City check. VHKW's public pages do not disclose the full owner fee stack, repair authority, reserves, statement and payout dates, contract term, termination, or future-reservation handoff. Guest-facing rating aggregates and stay reviews are not owner-contract evidence, and the available review bodies did not meet the RealReviews threshold for owner-sentiment synthesis. Managed rental homes that share VHKW's phone remain property listings, not duplicate company profiles.
Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available
Guest servicesLicensing and tax supportReservation management+5
★4.5 · 235 ReviewsReported by Google Places · not a RealReviews rating
At Home in Key West by AvantStay is the aligned local listing identity for AvantStay's current Key West vacation-rental management operation at 905 Truman Avenue. AvantStay's official local owner page advertises broad channel distribution, revenue management, local inspections, an owner portal, housekeeping, maintenance, guest services, monitoring, and damage protection. The completed research did not establish the exact date or legal mechanics of the legacy At Home in Key West brand transition, so RealReviews does not invent an acquisition date. AvantStay's Florida page identifies AvantStay Southeast, LLC as its licensed Florida real-estate broker under CQ1065931, but the direct DBPR result and exact entity that signs a Key West agreement still require confirmation. Published performance figures remain attributed company marketing without a local sample or independent audit. Public pages do not disclose the complete owner fee stack, repair authority, reserve, payout schedule, contract term, or termination handoff. Guest reviews of individual stays cannot establish owner-side fee transparency, revenue performance, reporting quality, maintenance cost, licensing work, or exit experience.
Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available
Damage protectionGuest and concierge servicesLighthouse owner portal+5
★2.5 · 2 ReviewsReported by Google Places · not a RealReviews rating
Pelagic Property Management is a Key West residential and commercial property-management operator at 5555 College Road. Its official site advertises residential, commercial, and industrial management; leasing and rent collection; photographed inspections; maintenance; monthly financial reporting; tenant relations; regulatory and workforce-housing work; vendor procurement; insurance evaluation; capital-project coordination; safety; and administration. A Florida Division of Corporations record inspected on July 26, 2026 identified Pelagic Property Management LLC, document L15000146266, as active at the same address. That filing resolves the entity but does not prove professional-license scope or service quality. The current public pages do not present a nightly vacation-rental distribution and turnover product, nor do they publish management fees, repair authority, reserves, markups, payout dates, contract term, or termination. An imported Foursquare-derived record shares the domain and address but carries an older phone; it is a duplicate data source, not a second company. RealReviews found no usable individual review corpus and therefore makes no recurring sentiment claim.
Review data available · Services listed · Quote request available
